Menards gutter guards vs. professional installation comparison from NorthStar Seamless Gutters

Menards Gutter Guards vs. Pro Installation in Eau Claire

You see gutter guards at Menards. The price on the shelf looks good. You may even think, “I could put these up this weekend.”

And for some homes, that can be a fair choice. But buying a gutter guard and installing a whole gutter protection system are not the same job.

Before you bring home a cart full of screens, here are a few things worth knowing.

Custom gutters and downspouts fitted around the rooflines of a classic Wisconsin home
Multiple rooflines require careful measurement, proper pitch and deliberate downspout placement.

What Does a DIY Gutter Guard Kit Include?

Big-box stores sell several types of guards. Some are plastic snap-in screens. Others use metal or fine stainless steel mesh. The quality and price can vary a lot.

The kit may give you the covers and some parts. It does not check whether your gutter is pitched the right way or whether the downspout is already clogged. That part is up to the person doing the work.

It is also important to compare the same kind of product. A thin plastic screen and a strong metal micro-mesh kit should not be treated as equal just because they share a shelf.

What Does Professional Installation Add?

A professional starts with the home, not the product box. The job may include checking gutter condition, measuring the runs, planning around roof corners, fitting and securing the covers, and spotting drainage problems.

This matters on taller homes and homes with steep or complex rooflines. It also keeps homeowners from taking on ladder work they are not comfortable doing.

At Northstar Gutter, we install gutter protection systems chosen for the roof and surrounding trees. We offer Spectra Diamond Cut screens and LeafBlaster Pro micro-mesh, with a reinforced LeafBlaster Pro option to confirm for specific jobs.

Which Option Costs Less?

A DIY purchase can cost less at checkout. But the shelf price is only part of the total.

Cost or taskDIY kitProfessional installation
Material purchasePaid at storeIncluded in project quote
Measuring and fittingYou do itInstaller handles it
Ladder and safety setupYou handle itInstaller plans the work
Existing gutter checkYou handle itCan be reviewed before installation
Time and cleanupYour timeIncluded in the scope of work
Repairs if neededSeparate decisionCan be discussed before quote approval

No table can say what is cheapest for every home. A simple ranch with good gutters is different from a two-story home with loose hangers and tall trees.

Will Store-Bought Guards Stop All Clogs?

No guard can promise that. Even fine mesh may need leaves brushed off now and then. Water can still back up if the downspout is blocked or the gutter is out of level. When exploring whether to use Menards Gutter Guards vs. Pro Installation in Eau Claire, please consider trees and other debris causing sources in your yard.

What matters most is matching the product to your home and keeping the drainage path clear.

When Does DIY Make Sense?

A homeowner with sound, easy-to-reach gutters may prefer to install a compatible kit. They still need to follow the maker’s directions and avoid work beyond their safe reach or skill.

But if the gutters are high, sagging, leaking, or hard to reach, a professional estimate is a smart next step. You can ask about adding guards to the gutters you already have before paying for a full replacement.

Why Local Fit Matters in Wisconsin

Leaves, pine needles, heavy spring rain, and freeze-thaw cycles can all affect gutter performance. The best choice is not always the guard with the biggest marketing claim.

A good system should let water move off the roof, into the gutter, through the downspout, and away from your home. That is the job the whole gutter system needs to do.

A Better Question Than “What’s the Cheapest Kit?”

Ask: “What will help my gutters work with less upkeep?”

Northstar can look at your gutters and help you weigh a basic screen, a fine mesh system, and any repairs that might be needed. There is no need to buy a full gutter replacement if the current system is sound.

Get a free Northstar gutter protection estimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Menards gutter guards all plastic?

No. Menards also carries metal and stainless steel micro-mesh options. Compare actual products and fit, not only retailer names.

Is a pro guard always better than DIY?

Not for every home. A safe, proper DIY installation can suit a simple roof. A professional is useful when access, fit, drainage, or repairs are more complex.

Can a professional install guards on old gutters?

Often, yes, when the gutters are in good shape. Learn more in Northstar’s gutter protection service.

Do I need new seamless gutters too?

Only if your existing system has problems that make a repair or replacement the better choice. See seamless gutter installation in Eau Claire.


Join the NorthStar Mailing List

Share this Article

Table of Contents

Explore more of our Articles.